Is a D&D Owlbear biologically possible, or is the famous monster just fantasy?

0
5

Of all the monsters available in Dungeons and Dragons‘ big bestiary, one has always fascinated me for how simple yet ludicrous it is: the owlbear. It’s a classic and imposing chimera of a design, but so funny if you think about it for even a moment. What advantage could an owl’s head possibly provide on a bear’s body? Wouldn’t you be better off, in pretty much every way, with just a standard bear?

Obviously everything in D&D can be handwaved away with ‘a Wizard did it’, but it’s much more fun to think how something like this could have arisen naturally. And I don’t think the answer is an amorous encounter between an adventurous bear and a very brave owl. Could an owlbear, a strange amalgamation of bird and beast, realistically evolve through the forces of natural selection?

A giant owlbear

Maybe! Right away, I think I have a plausible animal group narrowed down for this experiment. One which had a beak, and which scientists initially thought had to be a hoax thanks to its combination of mammal and bird-like features. Owlbears are quite clearly monotremes!

Beaks are common, useful structures found across multiple disparate groups, from squid, to birds, to fish. And often, as happened in birds and beaked reptiles like turtles, an animal goes from toothed to beaked, gradually losing its gnashers until it’s doing all its cutting and crunching with a hard beak instead. But because mammals have developed much more specialized teeth than other vertebrates, with different shapes and sizes adapted for different roles, they very rarely give them up.

An echidna

But monotremes (represented today by the platypus and the echidna) are one of the rare exceptions. They lost their teeth and – rather than the keratinized structures of other beak-bearers – developed a rubbery beak-like snout, which is not only used for feeding, but also gives them superpowers. They have special sensors within, designed to detect the electrical signals of their prey, just like sharks can.

While most useful underwater, perhaps an owlbear could use this to hunt down rabbits or adventuring parties too. Even at peak diversity, none have ever become large apex predators, but all monotremes are carnivores.

It seems plausible to me that an owlbear could be some distant relative of the echidna, an animal which already has the rough body shape of a bear – check out the Murrayglossus, an echidna from the Pleistocene that was over three foot long – if you don’t believe me. This would explain the sharp claws, the beak, and the feathers. Okay, that last one might need more unpacking.

A giant prehistoric echidna beside a cockatoo

I think an owlbear’s feathers could be derived from the hardened spines of an echidna-esque ancestor. Actually, this is one of its few owl traits that could be eminently useful. Owls are some of the most-feathered birds in the world, and this major fluffiness, as well as a serrated edge on the feathers which breaks up airflow, is what enables their super silent flight. Bears are already surprisingly stealthy considering their massive bulk, with soft foot pads and a flat-footed gait. So my hypothesis is that, while initially serving as spines for defence, the owlbear’s hairs may have gradually changed to their current feather-like appearance to help it sneak up on prey: a classic case of convergent evolution.

Obviously, we can assume its ancestors gradually started going after larger prey, and this allowed its body size to scale up in turn. But we have to take a bit more of a logical leap to explain how the tube-like snout of an echidna might become the sharpened beak of an owl(bear).

Monotremes have soft, rubbery beaks, not at all suitable for tearing flesh, and in fact they rely on keratinous pads on their tongues and inside their mouths to ‘chew’ their invertebrate food. You can forget about shearing through bone. But my guess is that it’s this keratinous pad, not the fleshy ‘bill’ at all, that forms the owlbear beak.

In the transition from a semi-aquatic lifestyle to a terrestrial, burrowing one, echidnas lost many of the electroreceptors in their beak, which may make it easier for it to be lost altogether. Perhaps, as owlbear ancestors started to eat larger animals like lizards or stirges, the spiked pad grew larger, and became more prominent, until it actually extended from the bill and ultimately replaced it entirely. Essentially, the owlbear rebuilt the beak from scratch. Obviously, it would have to lose electroreception for this to work, but that ability functions far better in the water anyhow, since air is less conductive.

So there we have it! A logical owlbear, forged through the powers of speculative evolution. Their beaks, feathers, body-structure, and egg-laying, can all be explained by their close relationship with the echidna.

I wonder if they also have four-headed penises? I’ll let you do the Googling on that one.

Check out our guide to DnD classes, or come join our community on the Wargamer Discord.

Source: Wargamer